Cacti Netgear Switch Template
Apr 11, 2018 - Table of Contents The real strength of Cacti is unleashed by using templates. There are three different types of templates with the basic Cacti.
| Thread Tools |
post #1 of 16Old02-18-2015, 10:31 PM - Thread Starter
Newbie
Posts: 11
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 10
8+ Gig Switch with SNMP/traffic monitoring suggestions
I'm looking for a gig switch that can give me per-port traffic stats for home use. I need a min of 8 ports, but would probably buy a 16 port (maybe even 24 port, depending on price)... I'd like SNMP stats available, but even if the only view in to the stats were a web interface on the switch, that would be fine for my needs.
The TP-LINK TL-SG2216 16-Port Gigabit switch looks attractive for the price (~$130 US). I'm wondering if anyone has this device (or another model from this product line), or if anyone can suggest an alternative that's near this price/port range?
Thanks!
The TP-LINK TL-SG2216 16-Port Gigabit switch looks attractive for the price (~$130 US). I'm wondering if anyone has this device (or another model from this product line), or if anyone can suggest an alternative that's near this price/port range?
Thanks!
| Sponsored Links | |
AVS Forum Special Member
Posts: 1,163
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 155
Originally Posted by chrisrocco
I'm looking for a gig switch that can give me per-port traffic stats for home use. I need a min of 8 ports, but would probably buy a 16 port (maybe even 24 port, depending on price)... I'd like SNMP stats available, but even if the only view in to the stats were a web interface on the switch, that would be fine for my needs.
The TP-LINK TL-SG2216 16-Port Gigabit switch looks attractive for the price (~$130 US). I'm wondering if anyone has this device (or another model from this product line), or if anyone can suggest an alternative that's near this price/port range?
Thanks!
I personally never used any of their switches but have heard good things about them and the price seems right. You could pick one up from a company (like Amazon) that has a decent return policy. The TP-LINK TL-SG2216 16-Port Gigabit switch looks attractive for the price (~$130 US). I'm wondering if anyone has this device (or another model from this product line), or if anyone can suggest an alternative that's near this price/port range?
Thanks!
Personally I use NetGear GS108T (Which is the Smart / Managed Version) Switches as well as Cisco Small Business Switches in my house and I've had no problems with them.
I have however had some issues with the Netgear POE Switches, they don't play well with their other switches and their firmware is / has been very buggy which is why I went with Cisco.
So for the money I would check out something like this Cisco 10 Port Managed.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16833150087
Sure it is a little more money but I am a firm believer that some things are worth paying extra for!
Denon AVR-X7200 - Klipsch RF-82 II Fronts, RC-62 II Center, RS-52 II Surrounds & R-112SW & Four CDT-5800-C II Ceilings for an Atmos 5.1.4 Setup.
Posts: 159
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 12
I'd get a HP 2910al J9145A. You can pick one up on ebay for roughly $300 or message me I've got 3 of them I'm not using. They are full layer 3 switches with SNMP stats and you can do pretty much anything you want with them. They also have optional 10Gb as well as next day lifetime warranty. If you have a problem with it HP will ship you a new one and you will have it by 10:30am the next morning. Also if you make config changes you don't have to reboot the switch, which is nice.
Last edited by crazyxbowler; 02-19-2015 at 11:57 AM.
| Sponsored Links | |
Member
Posts: 15
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 0
I've had issues with the Small Business Cisco switches. In particular there was one 48 port POE gigabit switch that would randomly lose its configuration. The lack of a real serial port was also a huge minus in my book as well (I hate trying to track down what IP the switch assigned itself).
Also take note those Small Business Switches are Linksys switches with a Cisco label on them. If you want a 'real' Cisco switch, go get a Catalyst.
The HP listed above is better than anything listed here. We happen to use HP Procurve at work. I have that exact switch in a remote office and know for a fact it will do per-port traffic statistics (Though I think this is common with managed switches).
Also take note those Small Business Switches are Linksys switches with a Cisco label on them. If you want a 'real' Cisco switch, go get a Catalyst.
The HP listed above is better than anything listed here. We happen to use HP Procurve at work. I have that exact switch in a remote office and know for a fact it will do per-port traffic statistics (Though I think this is common with managed switches).
Advanced Member
Posts: 987
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 71
Originally Posted by funhouse69
I personally never used any of their switches but have heard good things about them and the price seems right. You could pick one up from a company (like Amazon) that has a decent return policy.
Personally I use NetGear GS108T (Which is the Smart / Managed Version) Switches as well as Cisco Small Business Switches in my house and I've had no problems with them.
I have however had some issues with the Netgear POE Switches, they don't play well with their other switches and their firmware is / has been very buggy which is why I went with Cisco.
So for the money I would check out something like this Cisco 10 Port Managed.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16833150087
Sure it is a little more money but I am a firm believer that some things are worth paying extra for!
Can you let me know what issues you have had with the Netgear POE switches and which models you have used? I currently am using 2 and have no issues. I use the GS108PE and also have 2 GS116 and a 2 GS108 in my network.Personally I use NetGear GS108T (Which is the Smart / Managed Version) Switches as well as Cisco Small Business Switches in my house and I've had no problems with them.
I have however had some issues with the Netgear POE Switches, they don't play well with their other switches and their firmware is / has been very buggy which is why I went with Cisco.
So for the money I would check out something like this Cisco 10 Port Managed.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16833150087
Sure it is a little more money but I am a firm believer that some things are worth paying extra for!
Id like to report back to Netgear your issues.
Thanks,
Bob Silver
Netgear Networking Advisor
AVS Forum Special Member
Posts: 1,163
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 155
Originally Posted by bobsilver
Can you let me know what issues you have had with the Netgear POE switches and which models you have used? I currently am using 2 and have no issues. I use the GS108PE and also have 2 GS116 and a 2 GS108 in my network.
Id like to report back to Netgear your issues.
Thanks,
Bob Silver
Netgear Networking Advisor
Bob - Id like to report back to Netgear your issues.
Thanks,
Bob Silver
Netgear Networking Advisor
This was a few years ago, I bought a Netgear GS724TP which Netgear even admitted to me wasn't really ready for prime time at the time, they said that they did not make the switch or the firmware and I had issues getting VLANs working with my other Netgear switches, it would randomly reboot itself and was not stable at all.
Again this was some time ago so maybe they've worked out the issues? I couldn't deal the with instability even in my home network so I went with the Cisco SG's and they've been running flawlessly since day one.
As with just about every thing else in life these are personal preferences and completely subjective. I'd take a Cisco (even their Linksys version) over Netgear or HP any day.
Denon AVR-X7200 - Klipsch RF-82 II Fronts, RC-62 II Center, RS-52 II Surrounds & R-112SW & Four CDT-5800-C II Ceilings for an Atmos 5.1.4 Setup.
AVS Forum Special Member
Netgear Switch Gs105
Posts: 3,193
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 749
Originally Posted by chrisrocco
I'm looking for a gig switch that can give me per-port traffic stats for home use. I need a min of 8 ports, but would probably buy a 16 port (maybe even 24 port, depending on price)... I'd like SNMP stats available, but even if the only view in to the stats were a web interface on the switch, that would be fine for my needs.
The TP-LINK TL-SG2216 16-Port Gigabit switch looks attractive for the price (~$130 US). I'm wondering if anyone has this device (or another model from this product line), or if anyone can suggest an alternative that's near this price/port range?
Thanks!
I've had the TL-SG2424 for few years now and I'm very happy with it. They're excellent switches for the price. RMON and SNMP are both supported for stat gathering. The TP-LINK TL-SG2216 16-Port Gigabit switch looks attractive for the price (~$130 US). I'm wondering if anyone has this device (or another model from this product line), or if anyone can suggest an alternative that's near this price/port range?
Thanks!
post #8 of 16Old02-24-2015, 10:30 PM - Thread Starter
Newbie
Posts: 11
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 10
Originally Posted by funhouse69
I personally never used any of their switches but have heard good things about them and the price seems right. You could pick one up from a company (like Amazon) that has a decent return policy.
Personally I use NetGear GS108T (Which is the Smart / Managed Version) Switches as well as Cisco Small Business Switches in my house and I've had no problems with them.
I have however had some issues with the Netgear POE Switches, they don't play well with their other switches and their firmware is / has been very buggy which is why I went with Cisco.
So for the money I would check out something like this Cisco 10 Port Managed.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16833150087
Sure it is a little more money but I am a firm believer that some things are worth paying extra for!
Thanks for the suggestions! I have a friend that recently bought some NetGear smart switches on ebay for prices in my price-range, so they are on the table now! I'm also going to look in to the Cisco stuff - I didn't know they had anything in that price-range. I don't mind if they are Linksys or Cisco - I just need reliable with stats! Personally I use NetGear GS108T (Which is the Smart / Managed Version) Switches as well as Cisco Small Business Switches in my house and I've had no problems with them.
I have however had some issues with the Netgear POE Switches, they don't play well with their other switches and their firmware is / has been very buggy which is why I went with Cisco.
So for the money I would check out something like this Cisco 10 Port Managed.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16833150087
Sure it is a little more money but I am a firm believer that some things are worth paying extra for!
AVS Forum Special Member
Posts: 1,163
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 155
Originally Posted by chrisrocco
Thanks for the suggestions! I have a friend that recently bought some NetGear smart switches on ebay for prices in my price-range, so they are on the table now! I'm also going to look in to the Cisco stuff - I didn't know they had anything in that price-range. I don't mind if they are Linksys or Cisco - I just need reliable with stats!
What are you going to be using to gather the stats or are you just going to get them from the switch itself? Denon AVR-X7200 - Klipsch RF-82 II Fronts, RC-62 II Center, RS-52 II Surrounds & R-112SW & Four CDT-5800-C II Ceilings for an Atmos 5.1.4 Setup.
post #10 of 16Old02-24-2015, 10:37 PM - Thread Starter
Newbie
Posts: 11
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 10
Originally Posted by crazyxbowler
I'd get a HP 2910al J9145A. You can pick one up on ebay for roughly $300 or message me I've got 3 of them I'm not using. They are full layer 3 switches with SNMP stats and you can do pretty much anything you want with them. They also have optional 10Gb as well as next day lifetime warranty. If you have a problem with it HP will ship you a new one and you will have it by 10:30am the next morning. Also if you make config changes you don't have to reboot the switch, which is nice.
Thanks for the suggestion, but I think $300 is a little out of my range right now. I'll keep them in mind for the future though! Originally Posted by PuterDude
I've had issues with the Small Business Cisco switches. In particular there was one 48 port POE gigabit switch that would randomly lose its configuration. The lack of a real serial port was also a huge minus in my book as well (I hate trying to track down what IP the switch assigned itself).
Also take note those Small Business Switches are Linksys switches with a Cisco label on them. If you want a 'real' Cisco switch, go get a Catalyst.
Good to know - I'll keep that in mind and do some digging around for additional feedback! Thanks!Also take note those Small Business Switches are Linksys switches with a Cisco label on them. If you want a 'real' Cisco switch, go get a Catalyst.
Originally Posted by robnix
I've had the TL-SG2424 for few years now and I'm very happy with it. They're excellent switches for the price. RMON and SNMP are both supported for stat gathering.
Thanks - I've got a number of TP-LINK 'dumb' switches currently, so I may upgrade to one, or more, or their smart switches. I have not heard anything bad about them, and the price is right.post #11 of 16Old02-24-2015, 10:42 PM - Thread Starter
Newbie
Posts: 11
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 10
Originally Posted by funhouse69
What are you going to be using to gather the stats or are you just going to get them from the switch itself?
I'm planning to write a small python script and stuff them in to graphite. AVS Forum Special Member
Posts: 3,193
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 749
Originally Posted by chrisrocco
I'm planning to write a small python script and stuff them in to graphite.
Cacti will save you a lot of work. post #13 of 16Old02-26-2015, 12:46 AM - Thread Starter
Newbie
Posts: 11
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 10
24 Port Netgear Switch
Originally Posted by robnix
Yeah, Cacti and MRTG are both nice, but I'm already familiar with Graphite, and it is useful for lots of other stuff, so I just figured I'd roll my own snmp poller and stuff the data in there... but, I still need to do some research in to what's already out there that I can bend to my needs! AVS Forum Special Member
Posts: 3,193
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 749
Originally Posted by chrisrocco
Yeah, Cacti and MRTG are both nice, but I'm already familiar with Graphite, and it is useful for lots of other stuff, so I just figured I'd roll my own snmp poller and stuff the data in there... but, I still need to do some research in to what's already out there that I can bend to my needs!
Cool, let us know how it turns out. Posts: 159
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Liked: 12
If you are wanting a really good switch at the <$100 range this one is great. Has lifetime warranty and can do snmp. It will blow a Cisco small business or netgear out of the water. When you make changes you don't have to reboot it which is a huge plus in my opinion. This switch is on the same level as a enterprise grade cisco, not saying its better than a real cisco but its on the same level.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/HP-Procurve-...item19fc593b0b
http://www.ebay.com/itm/HP-Procurve-...item19fc593b0b
Senior Member
Location: Old Greenwich, CT, USA
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Quoted: 16 Post(s)
I used to buy Dell PowerConnect switches but now have purchased and replaced them with HP 1810-24G v2 switches purchased on Amazon. I found the low-end (i.e. affordable for home use) Dell switches purposely crippled their web traffic statistics. (showing only one direction of traffic). The HP switches have proven to be reliable, don't cause Sonos packet storms (a problem I had with the previous Dell generation of switches), and haven't needed a software upgrade in 6 months.
They also have an ability to do fiber uplinks which is useful for longer distance than cat5e/cat6 can handle.
They also have an ability to do fiber uplinks which is useful for longer distance than cat5e/cat6 can handle.
| Sponsored Links | |
| ReplyNetworking, Media Servers & Content Streaming |
| Posting Rules | |
You may not post replies You may not edit your posts Smilies are On HTML code is Off Pingbacks are Off | |
view our sponsors showcase AVS Forum is proudly sponsored by
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome
We use cookies to improve your experience on this website and so that ads you see online can be tailored to your online browsing interests. We use data about you for a number of purposes explained in the links below. By continuing to browse our site you agree to our use of data and cookies.
Tell me more Cookie Preferences
Tell me more Cookie Preferences